I can't check out with any option other than ShopPay.Updated 2 months ago

Yes, that is a bit confusing. Our checkout uses an automated feature, where if you've used ShopPay on a past order, it tries to automate the checkout by offering that option by default and prefilling in all your details.

You can change your payment method on your order by using the "Check out as guest" link below the Pay Now button. 

Just be sure to use the email address associated with your account so that you can see your order in your order summary and get rewarded with your loyalty points for the purchase!